In this episode of Multiple Perspectives, hosts David Lofgren sits down with  Rob Beardsley, founder of Lone Star Capital, to explore the evolving landscape of multifamily real estate investing. From building a 5,000-unit portfolio in Texas to navigating market cycles, Rob reveals why traditional value-add strategies can be overrated and how conservative underwriting, vertical integration, and location quality drive sustainable success. Whether you’re an LP or high-net-worth investor, this conversation delivers actionable insights for smarter real estate decisions.

Rob Beardsley is the Founder and CEO of Lone Star Capital, a Texas-based multifamily investment firm with over 5,000 units acquired since 2018. He has overseen $750M in transactions, leading acquisitions, financing, and vertically integrated property management through Lone Star Communities. Author of two bestselling books, including The Definitive Guide to Underwriting Multifamily Acquisitions with 25,000+ copies sold, Rob is a sought-after speaker and host of the Lone Star Capital podcast, offering practical insights on real estate strategy, risk, and operations.

If you enjoyed this episode, make sure to subscribe, rate, and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Google Podcasts. Instructions on how to do this are here.

Rob reveals how many new investors are drawn to value-add multifamily deals due to their apparent simplicity and potential upside. He explains that while value-add strategies can work, the success depends more on purchase price and market timing than the renovation plan itself. The strategy became particularly dangerous when capital markets stopped discriminating between asset quality, leading investors to take on riskier properties. High-income professionals should understand that Class A properties often perform better in downturns since tenants have more financial stability. For optimal risk-adjusted returns, focus on well-located properties with strong fundamentals rather than chasing higher yields through deep value-add plays. Conservative underwriting and realistic assumptions are crucial for long-term success in real estate investing.

Rob demonstrates how bringing property management and construction in-house can dramatically reduce costs and improve operational control. He shares a real example where their in-house construction team completed a $700,000 roof repair project for just $250,000, showcasing potential savings of over 60%. Professional investors should recognize that while vertical integration requires more upfront investment in personnel, the long-term cost savings and quality control benefits can significantly enhance returns. By maintaining an ownership mindset throughout the organization and handling repairs in-house, properties can achieve better financial performance. 

Rob provides crucial insight into the current commercial real estate market, noting that high-quality assets (B+ and better) likely bottomed in late 2023. He explains how market cycles affect asset quality pricing differently, with premium properties down roughly 20% while lower-quality assets have fallen up to 50%. For high-net-worth investors, this divergence creates potential opportunities in both segments of the market. The best-quality properties are already seeing increased competition and price recovery, while distressed assets may present opportunities for significant returns if purchased at the right time. Sophisticated investors should watch for signs of market improvement and capital markets stabilization before moving into more challenging assets.

Rob emphasizes how projected returns on paper often mask the true risk profile of real estate investments. He cautions that deals promising exceptionally high returns typically carry proportionally higher risks, whether through leverage, asset quality, or location. Sophisticated investors should focus on understanding the fundamental drivers of returns rather than being seduced by aggressive projections. The most sustainable approach involves building a portfolio of solid-performing assets that can deliver consistent returns over time.