Creating Standout Guest Experiences with Mark Lumpkin of STR Cribs

In this episode of The Vacation Rental Show, host Lynell Gordon sits down with Mark Lumpkin, Sales Director at STR Cribs, to explore how strategic property improvements and quality amenities drive success in today's competitive vacation rental market. With over a decade in the industry as a licensed general contractor, Mark reveals his "heads and beds" strategy for maximizing revenue through legal space conversions, why investing in quality amenities saves money long-term, and how themed properties eliminate competition by creating unique guest experiences. From transforming garages into profitable bedrooms to building Dallas Cowboys-themed retreats with original stadium seating, Mark demonstrates that understanding your guest avatar and focusing on exceptional properties, rather than managing hundreds of mediocre ones, is what separates successful STR investors from those experiencing declining revenues. This episode is sponsored by Bluetent.

In this episode of The Vacation Rental Show, host Lynell Gordon speaks with Mark Lumpkin, Sales Director at STR Cribs, about creating standout guest experiences in today's evolved vacation rental market where basic accommodations no longer generate premium returns.

What you'll learn:

The "heads and beds" strategy: how to legally convert garages and dining rooms into profitable bedrooms that double guest capacity and revenue
Why investing in quality, hospitality-grade amenities saves thousands compared to repeatedly replacing cheap alternatives that break seasonally
How to create themed properties (Dallas Cowboys, Taylor Swift, Star Wars) that eliminate direct competition and set their own rates
The critical importance of proper permitting and licensed contractor work to protect investments and avoid liability issues
Why property owners who don't reinvest are losing 10% revenue annually while competitors raise their standards
The hands-on approach new investors should take: personally cleaning, managing, and staying in properties to understand guest experiences
How to balance luxury amenities with practical durability based on market demographics and environmental factors
Why focusing on fewer, exceptional properties outperforms managing large portfolios of average-quality rentals
Market-specific amenity strategies: couples retreats in Tennessee vs. family properties in Orlando require different approaches
How 50-60% repeat and referral business demonstrates the success of quality-focused investment strategies

Mark Lumpkin is the Sales Director at STR Cribs and cohost of the STR Investing Podcast, bringing over a decade of experience in the vacation rental industry. As part of a licensed general contracting company, Mark specializes in transforming ordinary properties into highly profitable short-term rentals through strategic space conversion and amenity selection. His expertise spans themed property design, legal bedroom additions, and quality amenity curation that maximizes guest satisfaction and revenue generation. Mark's approach focuses on creating unique, competition-free properties that attract guests seeking experiences rather than just accommodations, proving that strategic investment and proper execution drive sustainable success in today's competitive STR market.

This episode is sponsored by Bluetent.

If you enjoyed this episode, make sure to:

Subscribe, rate, and review
Share this episode

Episode Resources:
👉 Apple - https://apple.co/3lYc2gU
👉 Spotify - https://spoti.fi/3InYanV
👉 Fame Host - https://bit.ly/hwg-podcast
👉 iheartradio - https://ihr.fm/3Z8qqlg
👉 RSS - https://bit.ly/how-we-grow-rss

The Vacation Rental Show is handcrafted by our friends over at: fame.so

Previous guests include: Jim DeVos of Best Beach Getaways, Stacy Wesson of Cascara Vacation Rentals, Michael Friedman of The Simple Life Hospitality, Steve Caron of Inhabit, John An of TechTape, Jessica Gillingham of Abode Worldwide, Justin Ford of Breezeway, Mahwussh Alam of One Perfect Stay, Lisa Stinnett of Inhabit, and many more.

Check out the three most downloaded episodes:

Are you a vacation rental industry leader looking to share your expertise? We're seeking innovative voices to join our conversation about growing and scaling vacation rental businesses.

The Vacation Rental Show reaches thousands of property managers worldwide. We're particularly interested in perspectives on:

Scaling your vacation rental portfolio
Optimizing guest experiences
Revenue management strategies
Industry trends and market insights

Express your interest in being a guest →