Keren Novack 0:00 Back in 2020, the plant based meat industry was just exploding. Why go against the category?
Hailey Swartz 0:06 What we first noticed is these products, even though they tasted good, they weren't that healthy for you. And the reason that people were going plant based was for health. So it just sort of seemed like a disconnect from what consumers were saying their reasons were for eating less also. Second was the environment. But number one, people really do think about themselves first. And it just seemed like this huge disconnect of what was being put out there and what people were saying they were eating plant based foods. But there also isn't really a good veggie burger in the grocery store right now. Like how I started this story. It's like you could get one at a restaurant, but it seemed like all the veggie burgers that were in the aisles were just like, antiquated. It hadn't been innovated on in like 20 years. And it was like, this is totally different than what everyone else is doing, which is why it was exciting.
Keren Novack 0:49 Products don't fail in the boardroom. They fail on the shelf. Every day, brand leaders face the same questions. Why do some products win while others don't? What do consumers versus what are we just assuming? And how do you build products that succeed in the real world? Well, that's exactly why we made this podcast. I'm Karen Novak. This is behind the Shelf and it's brought to you by Kurion. In each episode, I sit down with founders, product leaders, and industry experts to unpack what really drives product success. From innovation and testing to consumer behavior and market trends. No guesswork, no buzzwords, just real insights backed by real consumer data. If you're building, refining, or scaling products, you're in the right place. Today we're joined by Hayley Schwartz, co founder and CEO of Actual Veggies, a food brand built around a pretty simple idea. Vegetables don't need to pretend to be meat. When actual veggies launched, much of the plant based category was focused on making products look and taste as much like meat as possible. Hayley and her team went into the opposite direction. Their burgers and super fries are colorful, made with recognizable ingredients, and designed to celebrate vegetables rather than hide them. That approach has helped them grow into more than 15,000 retail locations, including Whole Foods, Sprouts, Albertsons, Kroger, and Costco. Today, we're talking about what happened once that big idea met real consumers. What people responded to, what the company had to change, and what actually drove that repeat purchase. Haley, welcome to behind the Shelf.
Hailey Swartz 2:32 Hi. Thanks for having me.
Keren Novack 2:34 Absolutely. Hayley, I love to do this. Before we go behind the shelf, I like to go behind you a little bit. I saw that you came from the technology world rather than the food industry. Tell us a little bit about what you were doing before actual veggies and how you found yourself building a veggie burger company. vack: Absolutely. Hayley, I love to do this. Before we go behind the shelf, I like to go behind you a little bit. I saw that you came from the technology world rather than the food industry. Tell us a little bit about what you were doing before actual veggies and how you found yourself building a veggie burger company.
Hailey Swartz 2:52 Yeah, it's a windy story, but I think, like, anyone who looks back at their career, they'll see the same thing. So I started my career in 2008. I lost my first job before I even started it, given the financial crisis. And when I was at the University of Michigan, I had an experience of running our online sales for the Michigan Daily. And that was an opportunity that led me to aol. I was sort of looking for my next job and I got to aol. I was on the advertising team. Really loved aol. It was a fun, like, place to be young in your career and trying to break things. And I ended up working on the AOL homepage. So I sort of started into my career. I was in tech. And then that eventually led to working at Alibaba. I was working with Alibaba.com, it's a B2B marketplace, helping entrepreneurs and small businesses connect with suppliers in China. And I was working with the Chinese counterparts in China to build out the Alibaba platform. And all day I was talking to entrepreneurs and small businesses about what they needed to source from China and then also to build their business. And it seemed like it was just a lot of fun to have their own business. I started to get the itch to do something on my own, and I met my co founder, Jason. Jason. I'm always very honest about this, but this is an idea that Jason had because he stopped eating meat for health reasons at the end of 2019, and basically he was looking to replace the meat burger. I actually do eat meat. I continue to eat meat even though I have a veggie burger company. But I love to eat really clean. Thought it was really interesting. There was a gap in the marketplace for this, like, restaurant style veggie burger. Something that, you know, you could get a great veggie burger at a restaurant, but you really couldn't find one in the grocery store. Like you said, everyone was focusing on making fake meat, but no one was focusing on making a true veggie burger. And we joined together to do it. Yeah.
Keren Novack 4:54 So back in 2020, the plant based meat industry was just exploding and people were pouring funding into this category. But what did you see that? Why go against the category.
Hailey Swartz 5:07 Why not just try to join with
Keren Novack 5:08 it and make an even better product? eah. So back in 2020, the plant based meat industry was just exploding and people were pouring funding into this category. But what did you see that? Why go against the category.
Hailey Swartz 5:07 Why not just try to join with
Keren Novack 5:08 it and make an even better product?
Hailey Swartz 5:10 Yeah, I mean, what we first noticed is these products weren't. Even though they tasted good, they weren't that healthy for you. And the, the reason that people were going plant based was for health. So it just sort of seemed like a disconnect from what consumers were saying their reasons were for eating less. I mean, also second was the environment. But number one, people really do think about themselves first. And it just seems like this huge disconnect of what was being put out there and what people were saying they were eating plant based for again. And then you looked at it and you're like, but there also isn't really a good veggie burger in the grocery store right now. And like how I started this story, it's like you could get one at a restaurant, but it seemed like all the veggie burgers that were in the aisles were just like antiquated. It hadn't been innovated on in like 20 years. And it was like you said, it was totally different than what everyone else is doing, which is why it was exciting.
Keren Novack 6:00 Yeah, absolutely. I was, I was a vegetarian for 14 years. So I know the struggle was real. And that was well before, you know, that was in like the early 2000s. So it was well before all of that. It was tough finding good substitutes for that. It's sort of, you sort of had to just go, ugh, no, I'll just deal with it. I've since evolved and I now say I eat a plant forward diet, but
Hailey Swartz 6:22 eat meat as well.
Keren Novack 6:23 And it's kind of well rounded.
Hailey Swartz 6:25 Veggies are the best.
Keren Novack 6:26 Veggies are absolutely the best. So it's just interesting to think about, like at that time, in 2020, around that time, right. Plus or minus five years on either side, people are going, I want to be healthier, therefore I'm going to not eat meat, therefore I'm going to eat a plant based diet. You almost got ahead of what the reason that they were even going down that path before the consumer even caught up with the idea that like, wait a minute, there's a lot of processed ither side, people are going, I want to be healthier, therefore I'm going to not eat meat, therefore I'm going to eat a plant based diet. You almost got ahead of what the reason that they were even going down that path before the consumer even caught up with the idea that like, wait a minute, there's a lot of processed
Hailey Swartz 6:53 stuff going into this healthy burger that I'm eating. Right? Yeah, that's exactly it. So when we first did this, the consumers weren't like, it was crazy. I remember this. We did this like consumer research and we showed this mom a picture of the ingredients in an impossible burger. And it was like, okay, like, and we're like, would you feed the staircase? And they're like, is it plant based? They're like, yes. And I was like, they did not even read that how processed the product was. It was just like the fact that they were being told to feed their kids plant based. That was all that mattered. The category managers or the people who are buyers for our products, they were getting a lot of fatigue of the whole foods buyers being presented the same kind of product over and over again. Fake meat, fake meat, fake meat. Everything's brown, everything's bleak, everything's processed and just different versions of fake meat. So they were really excited about seeing our new product because it was so unique to everything that they were seeing for the set. And it was really easy to sell into grocery stores because they're like, yes, I get it. Like this makes sense. Like it's something different, it's incremental to what we're doing. But you're right, it was about only two years later that the consumer came around and like, you really saw the media start to question what was in these plant based products. People starting to like to turn around and be like, actually, I want whole real foods. And it was really interesting to see that evolution because you're right, like at the beginning, like consumers weren't looking for a true veggie burger.
Keren Novack 8:19 Yeah. So the founding idea sounds compelling and eventually consumers caught on and we realized that it is in fact a very compelling idea. You don't really know until it actually hits consumers plates. So what did consumers tell you when they first got the products? It sort of validated your original ide or. Or what forced you to rethink?
Hailey Swartz 8:39 Yeah, people were so excited by how it tasted and I think that's great. And like that was the most validating piece is they're like, this is like so good. And there's sort of a surprise around on that. And they were really just like open to. I think it really exciting to see like meat eaters and vegetarians alike be so excited about our product.
Keren Novack 9:00 Is what I would say celebrating the vegetables, not trying to be something else. Right?
Hailey Swartz 9:05 Exactly. Yes.
Keren Novack 9:07 Yeah. Your products, delicious and distinctive, like the appearance can attract attention and earn that initial purchase. But maybe once the novelty wore off, what did you learn about what actually brought consumers back? ying to be something else. Right?
Hailey Swartz 9:05 Exactly. Yes.
Keren Novack 9:07 Yeah. Your products, delicious and distinctive, like the appearance can attract attention and earn that initial purchase. But maybe once the novelty wore off, what did you learn about what actually brought consumers back?
Hailey Swartz 9:20 Yeah, I mean, I think it's just a base. It's a good product and it's clean ingredients. And there's something about the convenience aspect of it as well. People are really excited about something that's easy to make and that's something we didn't think about at the beginning. But it's like just a quick meal that's both filling, tastes good, healthy for you, and then, like I said, it's easy to make. So the feeling good after eating it, I think just keeps bringing people back to it.
Keren Novack 9:45 Yeah, because vegetables are not actually that easy to eat on a regular basis unless you're happy eating them raw, which is fine for some of them occasionally.
Hailey Swartz 9:54 Right? Exactly.
Keren Novack 9:56 Yeah. So founders are told this all the time.
Hailey Swartz 9:59 And go to the farmer's market.
Keren Novack 10:00 Listen to your consumers, take everything, take every piece of feedback. Can you tell me about any feedback that you deliberately chose not to follow?
Hailey Swartz 10:10 I think at the end of the day, we sort of just look to ourselves at the beginning to see, like, what we thought tasted good and, like, we didn't overcomplicate it. It was just something. Was this something that we would want to eat versus other people? It was really important to us to not compromise what was in our product. And we really stuck to, like, only using whole and real ingredients. I think we got feedback that sometimes a certain filler would make our product taste better or something like that, or cheaper or anything. But it was really important to us to, like, stick to ingredients that we would want to eat.
Keren Novack 10:45 Yeah, just something about going with the gut.
Hailey Swartz 10:48 Like, at the end of the day,
Keren Novack 10:50 if this is something you want to eat, your consumers will as well. And really taking a step back and
Hailey Swartz 10:56 listening to this, I know sometimes it's just like, it's not that complicated. Like, I love to say that, like, you can make our product at home. Like, I would love to give you the recipe. I mean, it's just, it's long. But you could actually make our products yourself.
Keren Novack 11:08 That's incredible. And also, I'm not going to, because that sounds like an awful lot of work. So you hit the good taste and the convenience aspect of it, celebrating what
Hailey Swartz 11:18 is in the plate.
Keren Novack 11:19 So then you started expanding the concept and you moved beyond burgers into super fries, tots and some other sort of familiar formats. What did consumer behavior reveal or purchasing the habits reveal that gave you the confidence that you could go further with this? ley Swartz: is in the plate. So then you started expanding the concept and you moved beyond burgers into super fries, tots and some other sort of familiar formats. What did consumer behavior reveal or purchasing the habits reveal that gave you the confidence that you could go further with this?
Hailey Swartz 11:34 Yeah, I mean, like, consumers were just excited about a way to get veggies in easily. So that's sort of the, like, platform that we've expanded is like, how can you get people to eat more veggies? And that's not just like, looking at what, like, a vegan would want. That's just looking at what, like, everyone is trying to eat more veggies. And if you look at the data, it's actually like eating More veggies has now surpassed like getting more protein into your diet. So everything that we've built now is really about fun and delicious ways to do that. We've just launched our new. So besides our super fries, which have these added veggies, we just launched our new dino nuggets for kids which are like we have a sweet potato dinosaur nugget, a cauliflower dinosaur nugget, and a broccoli dinosaur nugget. And all of these are just all about like making kids excited about eating veggies.
Keren Novack 12:22 And on your package, do you celebrate the vegetables there? Because oftentimes we're trying to hide them from the kids. How did kids respond that?
Hailey Swartz 12:30 Yeah, so that was like a really fun, like consumer test that we did, which is like having so many different kids try our products. And like, yeah, there's definitely that balance of like hiding the veggies, but then making parents aware that they're getting the veggies for the kids in there. And that was just like, definitely. Like our veggie burgers have like a bunch of chunks of veggies in them. And parent. And people who love veggie burgers love that you can actually see the veggies. But you're right for the kids product we have to blend them more.
Keren Novack 12:57 But they're still made with so many veggies. Yeah. So just an element of disguise for the kids so that they don't necessarily know. I have made more than one deconstructed plate of food to know the pickiness of children. But it sounds like you've been very successful there. Looking ahead, what do you think the next generation of these successful plant based products look like?
Hailey Swartz 13:23 I mean, it's all about having real ingredients. Higher protein, I think is also is really important for people who eat like mostly veggie based. Like they're always looking for more protein, so using. But people are more and more aware of what's in their product. They know to look for it. I think something that's exciting is people now realize that they can get healthy frozen products. So they are actually shopping the freezer and looking for those products in the freezer as well. And I think before it used to be like the freezer, everything's totally processed. But now the consumer is learning that they can get like whole and real products in the freezer as well.
Keren Novack 13:58 Yeah. And be able to get it in a convenient sort of way. looking for those products in the freezer as well. And I think before it used to be like the freezer, everything's totally processed. But now the consumer is learning that they can get like whole and real products in the freezer as well. Yeah. And be able to get it in a convenient sort of way.
Hailey Swartz 14:02 Exactly.
Keren Novack 14:03 Give me a sense if you can kind of what's next for actual veggies.
Hailey Swartz 14:08 We just launched these dino nuggets so that's, like, what we're really excited about. They're at Whole Foods. They're at Select Kroger. And really, like, something that, like, we stumbled upon is, you know, obviously they're the Dino shape to serve kids, but there's a nostalgia and a excitement around the Dino shape for adults as well, because it's just. It's a fun shape to eat, and it doesn't feel like so kitt it. Like, it feels like something that anyone can enjoy, and it's just a really great product. I love that.
Keren Novack 14:35 Well, they were sold out at Mike Kroger. There was a space in the shelf
Hailey Swartz 14:38 for them, but they were not there. Yeah, they're just being put on shelf now.
Keren Novack 14:41 Okay. So maybe they were getting ready for them. There was a space there, and I couldn't because I really wanted to grab some for my kids. But we do love the veggie burgers because like I said, everyone's trying to get back to that kind of plant forward diet and just be able to do it in a convenient way. And so you're making it people able to be able to do that. So. All right, Hayley, I love to do these kind of shelf checks at the end. Couple of questions here for you. What is one food or beverage trend that you would invest in today outside of what you are?
Hailey Swartz 15:12 I was like, yeah, who wants to invest in actual veggies? No, I think anything that's, like, focusing on disrupting the freezer and whole and real ingredients, like, any product that is a better, cleaner version of something that's already on the shelf. I think I'm really excited about this trend of people, like, being aw what's in their food and caring about it. And I think you just see products that, like, the ingredient decks are just, like, getting better and better, like, and seeing that, like, across pizza and ice cream, and we're doing it in veggie burgers, and Evergreen is doing it in waffles. Like, it's just really fun to see that, like, the integrity of our food, like, just really increasing.
Keren Novack 15:48 Yeah, people are definitely wising up to that. And even in the snack food aisle, you know, walking down the aisle at
Hailey Swartz 15:54 Target, it's like the.
Keren Novack 15:54 The food there is so much more better for you than it ever was.
Hailey Swartz 16:00 I know Target's doing a really great job of leading the way in clean and delicious products. Yeah. And we as a society have the w, walking down the aisle at Target, it's like the.
Keren Novack 15:54 The food there is so much more better for you than it ever was.
Hailey Swartz 16:00 I know Target's doing a really great job of leading the way in clean and delicious products. Yeah. And we as a society have the
Keren Novack 16:08 ability now to put good food into package and feed people on mass. And I think. Yeah, I think you're absolutely right. That they're going to start demanding this. Consumers are going to start demanding this. So thinking about retail shelves too crowded
Hailey Swartz 16:24 or not innovative enough, there's always going to be room for something that's new and innovative. Like it really, like, I know this as having a emerging brand. Like, if you have something compelling, the grocery store buyer is going to find room for it. And like, it's so fun finding, like seeing what keeps popping up and seeing what's next. And you're always like, there can't be any new innovation. And then there is. And I love that. That's like the best part of this industry.
Keren Novack 16:49 Absolutely. What's the better predictor of long term success? Product experience or the branding?
Hailey Swartz 16:56 Product experience. A hundred percent. I mean, you're gonna buy something new because of branding. But it has to be like, it can't be too crazy. People are creatures of habit and they end up eating the same thing over and over again. So it has to taste really great and it has to meet the need. I always say to new founders, like, don't try to go too crazy. Like, the saddest part of having an emerging brand is you're like, people just like what they like and like, innovation can't be that out of the, out of line.
Keren Novack 17:28 You're probably the eighth episode I've recorded this season. And there is one common theme. Keep it simple. Innovation doesn't need to be crazy. Let's go back to the basics. Make a great product and something that consumers can understand.
Hailey Swartz 17:43 Yeah. And don't try to do something different with packaging. There's usually a reason that a package looks like the way it looks.
Keren Novack 17:51 Oh, that is probably some really wise advice. What is one thing behind the shelf that consumers never say? Everything.
Hailey Swartz 18:00 I mean, yeah, like on that line of like, thinking forward of how something actually, I don't know if like literally like fits on the shelf. Like, you have to have a package that can fit in the actual shelf. You have to have the dimensions correct so that it stands out, but it's not too big because then it can't fit on the shelf and then the category manager can't like sell it. So there's definitely a reason things are the way they are. And making sure you get the pricing, architect and everything in place because of that is really important.
Keren Novack 18:29 Yeah. So many details that go on behind the shelf. And then the consumer comes and just plucks it off the shelf and has all the expectations in the world. All right, let me round it out by what's one must have item on your grocery list these days. g in place because of that is really important. Yeah. So many details that go on behind the shelf. And then the consumer comes and just plucks it off the shelf and has all the expectations in the world. All right, let me round it out by what's one must have item on your grocery list these days.
Hailey Swartz 18:45 So my friend is the founder of Lao Bonh Dumplings and I really love those. I also not to like plug my own products, but I've been like eating our dino nuggets for breakfast. Like I can't stop eating them. They're so good. And it's like a really fun way to get veggies in. It's really easy to make. And the air fryer and like, I literally, because I don't have a better system, I am buying them myself at the grocery store.
Keren Novack 19:13 That is a true testament of a
Hailey Swartz 19:15 great product of the founder. I literally like, this is ridiculous. I need a better system.
Keren Novack 19:19 I feel like you might have the power to change that.
Hailey Swartz 19:22 Yeah, exactly like things to add it to the list. That's awesome.
Keren Novack 19:26 Haley. This is an awesome conversation. I really appreciate you joining me here on behind the Shelf. I love the story of how actual veggies just went back to the basics and celebrated veggies on consumers plates. Thank you for joining me.
Hailey Swartz 19:42 Thank you for having me.
Keren Novack 19:44 That's it for this episode of behind the Shelf. If you found this conversation useful, don't keep it to yourself. Share it with colleagues, friends, people who are building a business too. Make sure to like follow, subscribe so you never miss an episode episode. And if you want more real world consumer insights, stay connected with us at Curion until next time. Keep testing, keep learning and keep building products people choose.